Privacy in the Election Booth
Fast forward to this Tuesday (16 Sept) when our town held a special election for an ordinance allowing the sales of alcohol on Sundays. When I went to vote, I noticed the computers on which we were to vote were set up as always and the way apparently everyone else's that have them around the county are set up; facing the center of the room and the line to sign in as well as the line to vote. As long as the person stands directly in front of the machine and the observer is not catty-corner to the voter, the screen is blocked. But, if a person cares to observe, they can. This, I feel can lead to intimidation or coercion of a voter. Or a voter can perceive an attempt to intimidate or coerce. A voter showing up with their church group, nursing home, or community group can easily feel intimidated if they are voting contrary to the "group think". For example; a church member voting to allow the alcohol sales when his/her church has campaigned against this ordinance.
According to Ms Lillie Coney, Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) who was providing testimony before the U.S. Election Assistance Commission's Technical Guidelines Development Committee as they considered the subject of human factors and privacy in the voting place; "If the touchscreen is at a 75 or 80-degree angle to the horizontal, the view from the screen might be difficult to keep their ballot choices private or hidden from the view of people who are in the polling place, including other voters."
To go further on this issue; the Federal Election Commission has issued a set of Voting System Standards (VSS)14 that serve as a model of functional requirements that elections systems must meet before they can be certified for use in an election. The VSS state explicitly:
To facilitate casting a ballot, all systems shall:
[…] Protect the secrecy of the vote such that the system cannot reveal any information about how a particular voter voted, except as otherwise required by individual State law;15
and:
All systems shall provide voting booths [that shall] provide privacy for the voter, and be designed in such a way as to prevent observation of the ballot by any person other than the voter. (Privacy And Technologies of Identity By Katherine Jo Strandburg, published by Spinger 2005. ISBN 0387260501, 9780387260501)
I have not seen this done since the advent of the electronic machines. I can understand the difficulties with cables across the floor and the potential of accidents from voters tripping if the machines were turned away fom the voters and towards a wall. However, there is an easier solution. A simple screen, such as room dividers separating the machines from voters standing in the lines would suffice easily and inexpensively.



Hi Tophawg
Jalbate sent me your blog and I look forward to spending time here reading it.
I was an election judge last nov. and will be again for the general election. I help to set up the little booths and all for my precinct, and this is an issue that really bothered me; the booths were set close together, lined up shoulder to shoulder (due to the neccistiy of plugging them in). I went over and shifted them to a semi circle arrangement so that no one could lean back a little and see how the person in the next booth was voting.
There were a lot of little slipshod details like that that really make me question the whole process of casting a vote at the precinct level. A friend of ours would like to vote for Republicans here in the city of chicago. But because he depends on getting city contracts now and then to do electrical work, he votes Democratic-says they know how individuals vote and he's taking no chances. I'd always scoffed at his story, heard secondhand, ridiculing the idea that a ward captain could discern how an individual is voting...but now I get it-it's not difficult to arrange the booths to see voters' choices.
We met at Myrtle Beach at the last meet, if you recall. So glad Jal sent along your blog.
Reply to this
Myrtle Beach! What a great weekend that was! ;-)>
I have been in contact with the local election officials regarding this data and I recommend readers do the same. I think I will probably have to escalate to the state or higher levels as most poll workers and managers are comfortable with status quo.
Reply to this
I do agree that we really don't have any privacy when we vote. I am so tried of being so exposed.
Reply to this
Wow!, this was a real quality post. In theory I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real effort to make a good article... but what can I say... I keep putting it off and never seem to get something done.
Reply to this